Mother of cancer girl wins compensation

Ke Jiayun
Chen Lan, an online writer with hundreds of thousands of followers, is ordered to pay 10,000 yuan after accusing 3-year-old's family of misusing funds raised for her treatment. 
Ke Jiayun

The mother of a 3-year-old girl who died from cancer last year has been awarded 10,000 yuan (US$1,423) compensation from a writer who accused the family of child abuse and misusing funds people had raised for them.

Chen Lan was also ordered to apologize on her Sina Weibo account.

Minhang District People's Court heard that Wang Fengya had been diagnosed with cancer in November 2017 by a hospital in Henan Province’s Zhengzhou.

To raise money for medical treatment, her mother, Yang Meiqin, sought help online.

Later, however, questions were raised about how the money was being used and Yang received lots of critical messages.

Some of them were from Chen, who has hundreds of thousands of followers.

Between April and June last year, Chen made several comments on Weibo accusing the family of abusing the girl and saying that she hadn’t received any treatment. 

Wang died in May last year and her grandfather, Wang Taiyou, donated the 1,000 yuan or more that remained to a charity.

On May 25, according to some news reports, police confirmed that the family had raised more than 30,000 yuan from an online funding platform and over 2,000 yuan from WeChat red packets and dashang, or rewards, from video streaming.

Police said it wasn’t a criminal case as there was no evidence to indicate fraud or child abuse. 

On September 4, mother and grandfather sued Chen for posting false statements, releasing their address and misleading others to post negative comments. They felt their reputation had been damaged and demanded Chen stop the posts and pay 170,000 yuan compensation for mental suffering, medical and attorney fees and crop losses.

They wanted Chen to apologize in newspapers in Henan and Shanghai and on her Weibo account.

Chen said she hadn't intended to hurt the couple and all her online statements had sources.

After she confirmed the statements were false, she said, she had deleted them and made a public apology.

She said there was no evidence to support the claim that she should pay for medical fees or crop losses.

The court said Chen was an online celebrity with a large number of followers and her Weibo could be seen as having great influence. Although she had the right to comment on social issues and the information in her postings had sources, her accusations were not proper and should be considered as reputation infringement.

The court said Chen should apologize to Yang on her Weibo account and pay her 5,000 yuan for mental suffering and another 5,000 yuan for attorney fees. Yang's other demands for compensation were rejected because there was not enough evidence to show these losses had anything to do with Chen.

Since Chen's postings had targeted the girl's parents, the grandfather’s claims were rejected.

Following the verdict, Chen said she would appeal and sue Yang to return the 2,000 yuan she had donated. Chen also said she would require Yang to say where the money raised from the public had gone and to produce invoices for medical fees.

Special Reports
Top